The Recent Events on Mount Everest
From AP, May 28th:
I've followed this story, a week-running, now. As I sometimes do, when a news-story strikes a chord, or strikes me wrong, depending. I've followed this story,a week-running, now...mulling over various elements of the tale, wondering about accuracy, and the rush to judge.
So...for those out there of a less-obssessive nature, those who've noted this story in passing, and passed by? I'll recount the tale as I understand it.
For as I understand it, the story runs thusly:
Well, wait.
It's right up there, see? That part where it says "...left to die...", that part?
It's right there, and that's the heart and soul of the story.
The man died, died in a snow-cave, about 1000-feet below the summit. The teams that passed him by, sitting there crossed-legged in that snow cave, reported that he was near-death, anyway. That he didn't have proper equipment, his gloves weren't even right, his oxygen was gone, and what exactly could they do about any of that, anyway?
What could they do...there at the top of Mount Everest, over 29,000 feet above sea-level, the air whisper-thin, whisper-thin air chilled to 100-below...
What could they do?
From AP, May 26th:
Everest is littered with corpses.
So many corpses, as a matter of fact? They've become landmarks for climbers...look, here, the spot where "Green Boots" last stood, last stood, then fell into the snow. A dead climber, curled like a fetus, his green boots still pointing at the trail, as they have for years now.
And climbers see these boots, note...now, we're close.
Dear Lord.
Climbing Everest - the mountaineer George Mallory was the source of that famous response to the question Why?
Why would you want to climb that mountain?
And the answer, of course.
Because it is there.
A stupid response, in retrospect.
And I wonder if Mallory wished, as he lay dying in the snow so close to the summit of Everest in 1924 (yet another corpse on the side of Everest, a corpse not recovered until '99, a corpse that remained for decades there, amongst the other corpses).
Thought on those words and wished that he could take them back. Wished, maybe...for another chance, an opportunity this time to be less glib.
And a bit more respectful, perhaps.
A lack of respect - this, a recurring theme in Jon Krakauer's Into Thin Air, his account of a disasterous expedition up Mount Everest in '96, when eight climbers died. A gripping book - and difficult, in parts. Difficult, not to ponder some of the questions raised...the concept - I mean, just think! A moment...if the very air itself is so thin it cannot sustain human life for any long length of time, if the air is so cold your flesh freezes alomst instantly upon exposure...if the terrain is so forbidding, steep and treacherous?
Maybe someone's trying to tell you something.
But no.
If we can, the logic runs, well, why shouldn't we?
If we can...if we have the technology, if we have the money, the money! For even a cut-rate expedition up the summit will set you back at least $25,000...a fortune, even with borrowed boots, even with the dullest of sherpas to act as guide, the cross-eyed, asthmatic sherpa, perhaps.
A fortune, nonetheless.
And it's the money that sits at the root of this evil, the fortune paid by those climbers for this adventure of a lifetime. Because...to stop and assist a climber in distress? Might mean that the good Samaritan would risk his investment, might risk his or her chance at reaching that summit.
Snapping that photograph, there, by way of proof...
A tale to tell, at cocktail-parties for years, for some climbers...a tale to tell, where they might conveniently leave out such details as being "short-roped", literally dragged up the mountain by stronger sherpas...
Or a detail such as leaving someone else to die in the snow, in pursuit of your own goal.
As many climbers did in the case of David Sharp...for no one spoke publically about what happened until Mark Inglis gave that interview. With their radios and their oxygen tanks, they trudged past...
They still left Sharp behind.
But, then again, what do I know.
I don't climb mountains, and can only imagine feeling what has been documented by others. Who knows how I might respond, if placed in that situation.
Self-preservation is a mighty powerful thing.
But then again, self-preservation would stop me in the first place, from placing myself there.
Oh, I suppose I might feel differently, about such a dangerous and foolhardy spit-in-the-face-of-God thing...if I were dying, perhaps.
(I try to imagine circumstances under which I would want to attempt such a thing.)
If I was told that I had but a year to live? I might want to try such a thing...but that's a fairly extreme condition.
Dying, perhaps...or losing my sight. If I were losing my sight? I suppose I might want to see whatever I could, before the lights went out for the last time. To stand on the top of the world, and look out below?
Now, that would be a sight, a sight to remember...
Which leads us to the case of Lincoln Hall and Thomas Weber, two other climbers who were declared dead during this same expedition.
An avid mountain-climber, Weber was to be the subject of a documentary on this climb of Mount Everest. Not because he'd scaled four out the infamous seven summits of the world, not because he was losing his sight...but because of a disability he'd encountered:
From the bio of Thomas Weber, posted on the SightOnEverest.com website:
Well.
There's this old joke, which I assumed was Catskill in origin, and wasn't wrong, in a sense.
It was Henny Youngman, and the joke- oh, you've heard it before.
Doctor, doctor...it hurts when I do this...
And the doctor replies?
Well, stop doing that.
And it must have been so much funnier when Henny delivered it.
But the point is this: If the man experienced blindness while climbing to higher altitudes?
Well then!
I don't climb mountains.
Obviously, I don't climb mountains, as the answer here is simple in my mind and limited scope of experience, I suppose.
But in my simple mind...well.
I wonder if someone was trying tell him something.
Weber lost his sight, of course, climbing Everest. And shortly after losing his sight, his life as well, at a point only 150-feet from the summit.
So close, so far.
On the same run was Lincoln Hall, a man who'd tried Everest before, and failed. He reached the summit, then began his descent when the lack of oxygen felled him.
His sherpas gave up on him, after a reported nine-hour struggle to bring him back down the mountain. Faced with the choice of attempting to save a man who was no longer breathing, or risk their own lives...they gave up. Hall was reported dead, when the sherpas returned to base camp.
One problem.
Hall was still alive.
Initial reports that another team attempting to summit discovered him, called for help on the radio, then continued their climb?
Were mistaken, according to mounteverest.net, and those who reported the story to this website from the base camp. A climber by the name of Dan Mazur, according to later reports abandoned his climb, waited with Hall for help to arrive, gave him tea and oxygen - and did not continue his climb to the summit.
Saving the life of Hall, whose status, tenuous, but still - a miracle! Alive, after a night...out there. Dead, then not...how his family must have rejoiced.
I do not climb mountains.
(As I've previously stated.)
I do not, essentially because there are plenty of adventures to be had without risking life and limb, a multitude of adventures! Which do not involve the possibility of death...or, equally horrible.
The concept of leaving another to die.
Death should never be the potential price paid for an adventure, my logic.
And I ask myself...which, then, would be more fulfilling? Which story would I repeat with satisfaction and pride, which accomplishment?
The story of how I reached the top of Mount Everest?
Or the one where I did not...but saved the life of a man, instead.
I wonder.
But then again, I don't climb mountains.
BEIJING (AP) - Five foreign climbers lost their lives on the Tibetan side of Mount Everest over a single week, a news report said Sunday.
One of the dead was David Sharp, a British mountaineer who reached the summit but was left to die on May 15 as dozens of people passed by...
I've followed this story, a week-running, now. As I sometimes do, when a news-story strikes a chord, or strikes me wrong, depending. I've followed this story,a week-running, now...mulling over various elements of the tale, wondering about accuracy, and the rush to judge.
So...for those out there of a less-obssessive nature, those who've noted this story in passing, and passed by? I'll recount the tale as I understand it.
For as I understand it, the story runs thusly:
Well, wait.
It's right up there, see? That part where it says "...left to die...", that part?
It's right there, and that's the heart and soul of the story.
The man died, died in a snow-cave, about 1000-feet below the summit. The teams that passed him by, sitting there crossed-legged in that snow cave, reported that he was near-death, anyway. That he didn't have proper equipment, his gloves weren't even right, his oxygen was gone, and what exactly could they do about any of that, anyway?
What could they do...there at the top of Mount Everest, over 29,000 feet above sea-level, the air whisper-thin, whisper-thin air chilled to 100-below...
What could they do?
From AP, May 26th:
The team of New Zealander Mark Inglis, the world's first double-amputee to reach the summit, stopped to give Sharp oxygen before continuing to the top.
"The trouble is that at 8,500 meters (27,887 feet) it is extremely difficult to keep yourself alive, let alone keep anyone else alive," Inglis told New Zealand television. "We couldn't do anything. He had no oxygen, no proper gloves, things like that."
Other climbers said Sharp, presumably incoherent, had also taken off his jacket...
Everest is littered with corpses.
So many corpses, as a matter of fact? They've become landmarks for climbers...look, here, the spot where "Green Boots" last stood, last stood, then fell into the snow. A dead climber, curled like a fetus, his green boots still pointing at the trail, as they have for years now.
And climbers see these boots, note...now, we're close.
Dear Lord.
Climbing Everest - the mountaineer George Mallory was the source of that famous response to the question Why?
Why would you want to climb that mountain?
And the answer, of course.
Because it is there.
A stupid response, in retrospect.
And I wonder if Mallory wished, as he lay dying in the snow so close to the summit of Everest in 1924 (yet another corpse on the side of Everest, a corpse not recovered until '99, a corpse that remained for decades there, amongst the other corpses).
Thought on those words and wished that he could take them back. Wished, maybe...for another chance, an opportunity this time to be less glib.
And a bit more respectful, perhaps.
A lack of respect - this, a recurring theme in Jon Krakauer's Into Thin Air, his account of a disasterous expedition up Mount Everest in '96, when eight climbers died. A gripping book - and difficult, in parts. Difficult, not to ponder some of the questions raised...the concept - I mean, just think! A moment...if the very air itself is so thin it cannot sustain human life for any long length of time, if the air is so cold your flesh freezes alomst instantly upon exposure...if the terrain is so forbidding, steep and treacherous?
Maybe someone's trying to tell you something.
But no.
If we can, the logic runs, well, why shouldn't we?
If we can...if we have the technology, if we have the money, the money! For even a cut-rate expedition up the summit will set you back at least $25,000...a fortune, even with borrowed boots, even with the dullest of sherpas to act as guide, the cross-eyed, asthmatic sherpa, perhaps.
A fortune, nonetheless.
And it's the money that sits at the root of this evil, the fortune paid by those climbers for this adventure of a lifetime. Because...to stop and assist a climber in distress? Might mean that the good Samaritan would risk his investment, might risk his or her chance at reaching that summit.
Snapping that photograph, there, by way of proof...
A tale to tell, at cocktail-parties for years, for some climbers...a tale to tell, where they might conveniently leave out such details as being "short-roped", literally dragged up the mountain by stronger sherpas...
Or a detail such as leaving someone else to die in the snow, in pursuit of your own goal.
As many climbers did in the case of David Sharp...for no one spoke publically about what happened until Mark Inglis gave that interview. With their radios and their oxygen tanks, they trudged past...
They still left Sharp behind.
But, then again, what do I know.
I don't climb mountains, and can only imagine feeling what has been documented by others. Who knows how I might respond, if placed in that situation.
Self-preservation is a mighty powerful thing.
But then again, self-preservation would stop me in the first place, from placing myself there.
Oh, I suppose I might feel differently, about such a dangerous and foolhardy spit-in-the-face-of-God thing...if I were dying, perhaps.
(I try to imagine circumstances under which I would want to attempt such a thing.)
If I was told that I had but a year to live? I might want to try such a thing...but that's a fairly extreme condition.
Dying, perhaps...or losing my sight. If I were losing my sight? I suppose I might want to see whatever I could, before the lights went out for the last time. To stand on the top of the world, and look out below?
Now, that would be a sight, a sight to remember...
Which leads us to the case of Lincoln Hall and Thomas Weber, two other climbers who were declared dead during this same expedition.
An avid mountain-climber, Weber was to be the subject of a documentary on this climb of Mount Everest. Not because he'd scaled four out the infamous seven summits of the world, not because he was losing his sight...but because of a disability he'd encountered:
From the bio of Thomas Weber, posted on the SightOnEverest.com website:
For the last couple of years I have been suffering from an eye disorder that manifests itself at high altitude. As I climb higher my eyesight deteriorates, leading gradually to temporary blindness while at high altitude.
Well.
There's this old joke, which I assumed was Catskill in origin, and wasn't wrong, in a sense.
It was Henny Youngman, and the joke- oh, you've heard it before.
Doctor, doctor...it hurts when I do this...
And the doctor replies?
Well, stop doing that.
And it must have been so much funnier when Henny delivered it.
But the point is this: If the man experienced blindness while climbing to higher altitudes?
Well then!
I don't climb mountains.
Obviously, I don't climb mountains, as the answer here is simple in my mind and limited scope of experience, I suppose.
But in my simple mind...well.
I wonder if someone was trying tell him something.
Weber lost his sight, of course, climbing Everest. And shortly after losing his sight, his life as well, at a point only 150-feet from the summit.
So close, so far.
On the same run was Lincoln Hall, a man who'd tried Everest before, and failed. He reached the summit, then began his descent when the lack of oxygen felled him.
His sherpas gave up on him, after a reported nine-hour struggle to bring him back down the mountain. Faced with the choice of attempting to save a man who was no longer breathing, or risk their own lives...they gave up. Hall was reported dead, when the sherpas returned to base camp.
One problem.
Hall was still alive.
Initial reports that another team attempting to summit discovered him, called for help on the radio, then continued their climb?
Were mistaken, according to mounteverest.net, and those who reported the story to this website from the base camp. A climber by the name of Dan Mazur, according to later reports abandoned his climb, waited with Hall for help to arrive, gave him tea and oxygen - and did not continue his climb to the summit.
Saving the life of Hall, whose status, tenuous, but still - a miracle! Alive, after a night...out there. Dead, then not...how his family must have rejoiced.
I do not climb mountains.
(As I've previously stated.)
I do not, essentially because there are plenty of adventures to be had without risking life and limb, a multitude of adventures! Which do not involve the possibility of death...or, equally horrible.
The concept of leaving another to die.
Death should never be the potential price paid for an adventure, my logic.
And I ask myself...which, then, would be more fulfilling? Which story would I repeat with satisfaction and pride, which accomplishment?
The story of how I reached the top of Mount Everest?
Or the one where I did not...but saved the life of a man, instead.
I wonder.
But then again, I don't climb mountains.


























