Tuesday, May 02, 2006

One, please - United 93

United 93 opens on a pre-dawn motel room, and I mentally began to cringe at the images (prayer rug, Arabic tongue, facing Mecca).

Uh-oh.

But, but let's stop a moment.

Why would anyone want to make a film based on the events that took place on September 11th, 2001? What would be the motivation? What, to re-hash an event that had been re-hashed now, four-years-running, re-examine an event that has already been probed and scrutinized from every possible angle....

(How ironic...that very morning. Class, and the topic of discussion was controversial photographs, and at what point does a newspaper decide that a certain photograph was too...whatever, to show?

A series of images...oh, wait.

Stay with me a moment, while I digress.

One photograph shown? A grief-stuck woman, agony, screaming to the heavens while all around her, the corpses of several infants in the sand, an image from the after-math of the tsunami.

The professor paused, let this image sink in a moment, then studied the room.

Let's see a show of hands. Who would run this photograph?

I raised my hand, muttered absolutely.

The image jogged my memory, and I mentioned to the class that I had seen this photograph before, run in certain newspapers - but close-cropped, to feature only the woman, and the dead cut out.

A young woman, the row in front of me spoke up.

I think that's a better idea.

What, the professor asked her.

To crop out the dead infants?

Yes, the young woman replied.

Because...I mean, think of someone reading this paper, first thing in the morning, and they see a picture like this?

It might just ruin their day.)

________________________________________________________

(No, no, wait.

I didn't finish that thought, the intial thought.

One of the first images shown was an image of the instantly-recognizable surface of the World Trade Center, the side of the tower...

And the image of a body, falling.

And the body falls, is falling head-first...really only the out-line of the figure, no zoom-lens, no way to tell the gender of the victim, even. The figure, tiny...but stands out in sharp relief against the grey-black steel.

Just a body, falling.

Do you run that?

And I hesitated.

Then raised my hand, yes, I would.

The professor went on to explain that only a few newspapers did run that photograph, and one apologized afterward, so heated the response.

And that the photographed was heavily hit, when it was posted on the Internet, with many down-loaders studying the photograph, Photoshop, trying to zoom in to see?

The face.

And that thought made me shudder. Because the photograph, as it stood, was quite enough. It would become unbearable, if one could see the face of the victim.

The distance made it quite enough.)

_________________________________________________________

So, here you have United 93, a docu-drama which attempts to zoom in on one aspect of this terrible day, zoom in on one of those four planes, and examine the faces there.

And I cringed, the opening shots.

My worst fear was that of the obvious...because why make this film at all?

I feared explotation. The explotation of tragedy, presented for an audience eagerly waiting to be titillated, even as they feign horror.

But United 93 is a bit too clever for this...names are left out to the point where no one seems to have any identity at all. There's the air-traffic controller, the military-guy, the pilot, the stewardess, the passengers, the terrorists - no one seems to have a name.

Nor is the cause named.

As it was that day? The terrorists and their motive remain a mystery.

The camera-work is jittery, hand-held stuff, adding to the sense of immediacy, urgency, adding later to the atmosphere of chaos and confusion. The dialogue appears improvised, and at the beginning of the film is so stilted and flat? It made me wonder if the air-traffic controller who initially alerts his supervisor to the possibility of a hijacking was a real air-traffic controller, and not an actor, for no actor would have delivered the line I think we got a hijacking here in such a dull fashion.

The dialogue, thankfully, picks up, then flows with the action, when the action does begin...and sounds realistic, laced with obscenties and hesitation.

But of course, it's the final twenty minutes of the film everyone wants to see - or, rather, don't let me speak for you. It's the final twenty minutes of the film that I wanted to see, wanted to see how the filmaker depicted exactly what he supposed took place on that plane. That car-wreck rubber-necking, you know, the compulsion!

To see...

The story of what exactly took place on that plane was one shinning moment in the aftermath of the event, and the concept that the bravery of the passengers took that plane down and away from the potential targent in the heart of Washington.

The oft-repeated Let's roll, you know...

Explotation, and worse still? Jingoism, a particular brand of American bravery (as I recall commentators saying, or words to that effect, a testament to American bravery).

So, I braced myself, for the final sequences.

Which actually quite well-done, well-acted, and captures the confusion and desperation aboard. Let's roll is a tossed-off line, a line you'd barely notice if you weren't listening for it admidst the chaos.

And then, of course, abrupt blackness.

_______________________________________________________________

Would I recommend this film, to you?

Well...no.

It'll...it'll just ruin your day, if you're that type.

Otherwise, go, go and see how a tragedy might be re-told for the screen that doesn't exploit the worst, but rather finds a way to celebrates the best of humanity.

2 Comments:

Blogger Shane Wilson said...

What's embarassing is, I was a little hesitant as I read your discussion of the film, because I didn't want to read too much information in case I saw the film.

In other words, I was worried about spoilers.

Spoilers. For the film about the September 11 plane.

I may not deserve to have my day ruined.

2:12 PM  
Blogger Charlotte Nieburg said...

And, if you're embarassed?

Imagine how I must have felt, imagine me, actually on the edge of my seat for many scenes from the film...excruciating suspense, in a few sequences. And how I chided myself later...said As if you never heard this story...

I was fully prepared to hate this film, by the way.

Hyper-critical, as I normally might be...after paying $10.75, that is.

And so, for me to endorse this film after paying what I still consider to be an exorbitant amount- for admission into a theater which, by the way, did not serve coffee?

High praise, indeed.

C.

6:28 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home